Nutrition

Why 'Eat less' is pointless advice

Why 'Eat less' is pointless advice

Therefore when I work with clients I aim to find the best way to control energy intake. THERE IS NO ONE BEST WAY TO DO THIS. This is where you distinguish a 'Coach' from a 'Personal Trainer'.

A coach should have multiple 'tools' to use with clients, rather than just 'their way'. When the only tool you have at your disposal is a hammer, you only see nails!

There are LOTS of ways to control intake, including: -

  • Counting calories: This could be through the use of fitness apps such as 'MyFitnessPal". Here a client is given a calorie target they aim to achieve on a consistent basis. Counting calories can be laborious, but I also find it an extremely useful tool for clients to understand the calorie content of foods they like to eat. It is educational in this sense.

  • Substituting foods: For example, aiming to cut out calorie dense foods, especially calorie dense foods that provide little in the way of nutrients (such as junk food) and replacing with foods with a far lower calorie content. For example, replacing your mid-afternoon biscuit with a piece of fruit. Replacing your soft drink with water. This method involves no counting of calories, but you are lowering intake by opting for foods that are naturally lower in calories and far more nutrient dense (such as vegetables, fruit, meat, fish etc).

  • Using a dietary approach that eliminates certain foods (such as Paleo, Ketogenic etc): For some people adopting a rigid dietary approach can work really well. Some people need the mindset of being 'on' a diet to adhere to the plan. Often the reasons diets such as the Paleo diet work well is that force better dietary choices because of their restrictive nature. For example, on the Paleo diet, you cannot eat dairy or gluten or processed sugar. As a result you cannot eat a whole swathe of foods such as sweets, chocolate, biscuits, cakes, pastries, pies etc. The focus is on whole foods that are unprocessed, so as a result people will tend to consume far fewer calories.

  • Changing your food environment to assist with healthier eating: Here I borrow heavily from the great work of Brian Wansink who has written extensively about people's 'food radius' in his book 'Mindless Eating'. Wansink's argument is that you cannot solely rely on will-power all the time to lose weight. By constantly saying 'no' to tempting food and feeling like you are constantly depriving yourself, you erode away at your will power, and at some point, it will give. His argument is that we must adjust our environments (home, work, supermarket) so that we don't have to keep making choices. Here are just a few examples from his book: -

Fast Improvements....

Fast Improvements....

Fasting, whilst being an ancient practice, has gained a great deal of popularity within the fitness and health circles recently due to it supposed benefits to health and weight management. This week's article comes from one of my clients, Eric, who's story and transformation can be seen here. In this article, Eric gives a great insight into how he felt during a recent 3 days fast. Enjoy!

Protein: How Much & How Often?

The main dietary sources of protein come from: -

Animal Sources: Meat, poultry, fish, eggs and dairy products 

Plant Sources: Grains, legumes, vegetables

Generally-speaking, animal sources are viewed as ‘high-quality’ or ‘complete’ sources of protein as they contain all the essential amino acids needed by humans. Most plant sources of protein are known as ‘low quality’ or ‘incomplete’ proteins as they lack one or more of the essential amino acids. This is why vegetarian and vegan diets need to be carefully planned to ensure that all essential amino acids are derived from the diet. For example, legumes are often consumed with grains as their amino acid combinations are complementary.

How Much Protein Do I Need?

Recommended Intakes for strength training individuals is 1.6-1.8g per kg of bodyweight. Therefore for an 80kg person this relates to a daily intake of between 128g-144g of protein per day. There is no research to suggest more muscle can be built with intakes higher than 1.8g/kg. For example, Hoffman et al (2006) found no support for protein intakes greater than 1.6-1.8g/kg in collegiate strength & power athletes for altering body composition.

Instances where it can be argued that a slightly higher intake may be optimal is in the case of beginner trainees embarking on strength training. In this scenario you could bring intakes up to 2.0g/kg of bodyweight. This is because beginners can expect to build large amounts of muscle mass when embarking on a strength training program.

Vegetarians will generally need an intake of 2.4g/kg of protein per day. This is due to the lower quality of pant-based protein which means less of the protein is absorbed by the body.

For the average gym goer who isn't looking to maximise muscle mass and just wants to lose a little weight, intakes of 1.2g/kg-1.4g/kg will be more than sufficient in maintain lean mass whilst losing body fat.

Benefits of Higher Protein Intakes: -

  • Enhanced Muscle Building: An insufficient protein intake will impair someone’s ability to build muscle. This is bad news whether your goals are to build muscle or lose fat because having more lean muscle mass is important to both processes.
  • Higher Thermic Effect of Food (TEF): The thermic effect of food relates to the amount of energy required to digest and absorb food. Of the 3 macronutrients, protein has the highest TEF. In practical terms this means that your body will expend more energy digesting and absorbing a high protein diet than a low protein diet, aiding in fat loss.
  • Satiety: Protein is also the most satiating of the 3 macronutrients. This is excellent news for anyone wanting to lose fat, as having a high protein diet will keep them feeling fuller for longer, reducing the chance of snacking and over-eating.
  • Reduced Chance of Sarcopenia: Sarcopenia is the involuntary loss of muscle mass with age, and affects up to 25% of older adults (Gregorio, et al, 2014). Women in this study who protein intakes below 1.1g/kg had higher body fat and fat-to-lean ratios than those who consumed a higher protein intake. Higher protein intakes can offset the loss of muscle mass with ageing, which is vital to health and well-being in the older populations.


Protein Distribution

Now we know how much protein we should be consuming, it is important to consider how the protein should be distributed across the day. Traditional dietary patterns generally has protein intakes skewed towards the end of the day, with a small intake at breakfast (which is usually more carb-heavy), a moderate amount at lunch, and a larger, bolus dose of protein with the evening meal. However, for the stimulation of muscle growth, a more even distribution across all meals is more effective (Mamerow, et al, 2014). This is because the body has a limited capacity to store excess protein from a single meal and acutely stimulate muscle growth at a later time, it is better to take more of an even distribution across meals throughout the day. For example, a 90g serving of protein has no greater effect on muscle protein synthesis than a more modest 30g serving.

Leucine Threshold

Leucine is one of the 9 essential amino acids, and is particularly important for us to consider as it stimulates mTor, which is highly important for muscle growth (Norton & Layman, 2006). To optimise muscle growth the total daily intake of protein is vital, but so too is the optimal intake of leucine. It is fairly easy to ensure you consume enough leucine if you follow the recommended intakes in this article and you consume a complete source protein with each meal. To ensure you meet your leucine requirements, you should consume 3g/kg of protein from a complete source in each meal. So for an 80kg individual this equates to 24g per meal. Reaching the leucine threshold in every meal is another reason why a more even distribution of protein is better than a skewed distribution, as the meals with only small amounts of protein may not reach the leucine threshold and as a result won’t stimulate muscle protein synthesis.

In Summary: -

  • Protein intake may vary slightly, but generally speaking, for most strength trainees, an intake of 1.6-1.8g/kg is the recommended daily intake
  • Higher protein diets are beneficial for increasing muscle mass, increasing the TEF and Increasing satiety
  • Protein intakes should be evenly distributed across all meals of the day

Training Through Stressful Periods in Life

Having recently encountered a cortisol-inducing period in my life, I want to share my thoughts on training during stressful periods. No matter who we are, we will always encounter unusually stressful periods in life. This may be because of work, or relationship issues, or finances, or all 3 at once! However, the fact is, life will always throw a curve ball at us. And we can either choose to stand there and get hit in the face with it, or we can duck it and move forward with greater resilience and tenacity than ever before.

When we go through periods of high stress, physiologically we are operating on catecholamines (adrenaline, noradrenaline). We are at the mercy of the parasympathetic nervous system, and we spend far too little time in the 'rest and digest' mode of the sympathetic nervous system. As a result we are wired. We are on edge. We are anxious. We are nervous. Our appetite disappears. We fidget. We cannot concentrate. 

As a result, it is wise to alter your training stimulus. Ultimately, training is a stress on the body. When our coping resources are stretched, we aren't sleeping optimally, our nutrition is nowhere near as good as it should be, we cannot expect to train at full capacity. As a result I advise dropping the volume of your training.

Volume here refers to the amount of work carried out in a workout: -

Training Volume = Sets x Reps x Weight

In this case I advise reducing volume by cutting the number of sets you do by around 1/3. Therefore do 2 sets instead of 3. Or 3 sets instead of 5.

Another thing I advise is to avoid training too close to failure on any of your lifts... particularly on big lifts such as Squats, Deadlifts, Bench Presses, Pull Ups etc. Going to failure on any exercise is extremely taxing on the body. Therefore, as a general rule of thumb I would advise leaving at least 1-2 Reps in Reserve (RIR).

So lets say your program has 3 sets of 8 squats. Reduce the number of sets to 2. Then we need to be careful to select a load that we will be able to complete 8 reps with good form, leaving 1 or 2 reps in reserve. 

By following this protocol, you will be able to continue training during stressful periods without overdoing things. The worse thing you can do during stressful times is to stop altogether. It is far better to continue training with a reduced volume, than stop altogether. 

Once external stressors start to die down, you can then start to ramp up your training again. As much as the fitness industry tries to promote a hardcore 'no pain, no gain', 'train hard or go home' attitude, it is often wise to look past this and think more long-term. Your body will thank you for it.